8/10 Very good
I booked a while ago and there were very few reviews, but the price was literally half to a third of the price as other places to stay in the area. When it was time for my trip I saw all of the negative reviews, and was honestly worried, I'd come for a work conference, and was afraid I wouldn't be able to sleep.
I will note, I stayed Sunday night- Friday morning, I would assume the quietest nights, but I was able to sleep, the bars were a bit loud, but I put in earplugs, that were provided, and set the AC fan to ON instead of Auto, that created white noise, and slept just fine.
The sheets were a little tattered, there was some wonkiness, like the end table lamps that were so large and heavy that the night stand shelf was bending, the mattress only sits about 3in off the ground, it would have been nice to have a little light in or by the closet, and one by the kitchenette area.
It's definitely not for all people, it's on a busy street, in the center of the night life area of San Diego, the roads are shut down with barriers at night, in the morning the restaurant/bars are still cleaning, and doors in the hall are propped open with garbage cans, one morning there was a garbage can in the elevator, there is a serious amount of homelessness in the area, and there were some folks sleeping in the street and picking through the trash in front of the bars in the morning, but they were all pleasant, no one was panhandling.
However, it's also walking distance to the convention center, trolleys, the bayfront, baseball stadium, and in the heart of the Gaslamp District. The room had a little kitchenette, free access to a laundry room, and they provided some laundry detergent pods, so it was nice to do laundry before I left, and head home with a suitcase full of clean clothes. Honestly, had the sheets not been tattered, I probably would have given it a 5 star review. Remember, other places in the area are at least double the price.