Airbnb
We had an amazing stay for two nights as a family of four with two young kids. My spouse and I come up to NY for work often so we know the city fairly well, including standard hotel sizes/rates. This is well above the rest in terms of size - it has 2 full bathrooms with tubs, a full service kitchen, living room, walk-in closet, and dining area. If you’re booking as a family, you could easily fit 2 younger kids in the sofa bed and 2 more kids on the floor in the living room, while still having a separate bedroom and bath for adults. There is truly nothing else we’ve seen in NY at this size for this price. Staying in the financial district is quiet and safe, and we easily got up to lots of touristy things in Midtown on multiple express trains that stop at the Wall Street subway stops (10-15 min train ride). We would absolutely stay here again if traveling as a family!